Grab A Slice at The Best Outer Banks Pizza Places

The Outer Banks is home to gorgeous views and fantastic attractions. You can do so much when you book an Outer Banks vacation rental. You can hit the beach or explore barrier islands. After a long day, you’ll need to stop for pizza. If you’re looking for pizza near the Outer Banks, you’re in luck! There are so many amazing places you can try!

Nag’s Head Pizza Company

Nag’s Head Pizza Company started as a dream between friends, a dream around creating inclusive, fresh, delicious pizza! Founders Lewis, Hilarey, Steve, and Kevin, wanted a work change in their lives, and wanted to open a unique pizza restaurant in their home town of Nags Head. They didn’t want to be just another Italian pizza, or New York pizza place, they wanted to create fresh and healthy foods for people with all kinds of tastes.

Part owner, Hilarey, has some special dietary restrictions herself, so it’s important to the team that there is something on the menu for everyone. The menu includes a section for vegan specialties, like Hayley’s Comet, topped with fresh spinach, banana peppers, roma tomatoes, and roasted mushrooms. Or if you are a vegetarian, check out Steve’s Jam! With bruschetta, fresh basil, and ciliegine mozzarella. Of course, you can also get classic like a Meat Lovers, or one of Nag’s Head Pizza Company’s own recipes like Paja Bay, or the Hulk Smash.

There are also options like fresh salads, whether you order a NHPC original or build your own. The best part is, Nags Head Pizza Company is just a few minutes drive from most of our Nag’s Head vacation rentals!

pizza on a tropical leaf — Photo from Shutterstock

Vinny’s Pizza Joint

Vinny’s is a classic New York style pizza and sub joint right in the heart of Nag’s Head, and is an absolute favorite favorite pizza place on the Outer Banks. The owner and founder, Vinny Caggese, has been making authentic pizza for his entire life. Vinny’s family is originally from Sicily, so you know you are in good hands!

Vinny’s offers classic pizzas, like the Supremo Originale, and the Margarita Pizza. They also have twists like the Lasagna Pie, featuring home made meatballs, and mozzarella cheese. You can also try “Meat The Don”, with pepperoni, bacon, ham, sausage, and meatballs. If you have some dietary restrictions, any pizza can be made vegan, and there are gluten free crust options as well!

Over on the sub side of things you will find all the staples, from Philly Cheese Steak, to a Meatball Sub. You just can’t go wrong! Vinny’s will also deliver with orders over $25 to Kitty Hawk and Kill Devil Hills.

Pizzazz

Perhaps you’re staying in a Nags Head Vacation Rental and want to sample some of Outer Bank’s pizza at its best. Pizzazz makes each pizza with only the freshest and finest toppings. All the meat here is fresh and local. Pizzazz is a local family-owned and operated pizza company. They have expanded their restaurant to four locations on the Outer Banks. All the dough for their pizzas is made fresh daily. The same goes for their sauce! You’ll always get the freshest pie directly from their ovens every time you walk through the door and order from them.

You can build your pizza in one of three sizes and have it topped with whatever you want! They even serve specialty slices like their California White, Hawaiian, and The Greek. Pizzazz also has sides and substitutes if you’re looking for something else besides pizza. You can make it a full dinner with Mozzarella sticks, Garlic Cheese Bread, and a personal pizza of your design. Pizzazz even has a full menu of subs and salads for you to enjoy! You can even have Pizzazz deliver directly to your front door when you stay at a Nags Head vacation rental.

pepperoni pizza slices — Photo from Shutterstock

Pizza Stop

Whether you want a curbside pickup or an easy delivery, Pizza Stop can serve you however you like. When you’re here on the Outer Banks, you can pick yourself up some New York Style Pizza! They keep the authentic New York Style when they make their pizzas. They are local and family-owned and love to meet new customers. Pizza Stop makes sure that they are one of the places to find the best pizza on the Outer Banks.

All dough is made fresh daily using bottled mineral water. The cheese is shredded in-house. All of their other dishes are also made fresh! You’ll find hoagies served in Amoroso rolls, fresh salads, wings, and pasta dishes. Pizza Stop also has a wide selection of domestic and craft beers for you to enjoy. You’ll be able to fill your pizza cravings when you order from the Pizza Stop.

Cosmo’s Pizza

When you stay at an Outer Banks vacation rental and look for great Outer Banks pizza, Cosmos’s is your place. Cosmo’s Pizzeria is located at The Marketplace in Southern Shores and offers authentic New York-Style pizza sure to delight. They ensure they use the highest quality ingredients, so you get the best pizza every time you order from them. They have traditional pizza, but they offer specialty pizza as well! You can have a classic Margarita pizza or even a BBQ chicken pizza. You have your choice of any topics when you order with Cosmo’s!

Perhaps you don’t want to have pizza. Cosmo’s also offers salads, pasta, and subs. Cosmo’s has a beer list that includes domestics and imports, wine by the bottle or the glass. You can have fountain soda or bottled drinks as well. Cosmo’s has everything for the perfect night out after a day on the Outer Banks. If you’ve got a sweet tooth, you need to sample their desserts. Cosmo’s is famous on the Outer Banks for having the best cannoli around! Cosmo’s is open year-round, so you can stop into Cosmo’s for a fantastic meal no matter when you vacation in an Outer Banks rentals. After eating your delicious dinner, check out some of the best places to grab ice cream on the Outer Banks!

Whether you are staying on the Outer Banks or in Nags Head, there is a rental that is perfect for you. You deserve to stay in the most luxurious rental after a day of fun in the sun and a night out at one of these exquisite Outer Banks pizza restaurants. Each rental from Cola Vaughn Realty comes with spacious rooms perfect for lounging around after a day out exploring. Your rental also features a large dining room and newly renovated kitchens perfect for ordering some pizza for the night. You can heat your pizza in your state-of-the-art oven if you want. Your Outer Banks vacation rental is your home away from home on your trip.