Where To Find Ice Cream and Other Desserts on the Outer Banks

A vacation on the Outer Banks means an ocean adventure like nothing else. From sandy beaches to bright blue waters, to hang gliding, kayaking, kiteboarding, and more, there’s something for everyone – and our Outer Banks oceanfront rentals put you right in the middle of it all on the Outer Banks. It really is a place for the whole family.

And after a sweet day of adventure in Nags Head, Kill Devil Hills, and the other towns of the Outer Banks, what could be better than a sweet treat? Let’s take a closer look at where to get dessert on the Outer Banks to help you top your day off right!

Ice Cream Shops in Nags Head

If you’re looking for a great Nags Head ice cream experience or the perfect Kill Devil Hills ice cream adventure, we’ve got you covered. There are many choices, so read on to find the best Outer Banks ice cream shops.

Booty Treats

delicious ice cream on the outer Banks — Photo From: Shutterstock

With two locations, Booty Treats can serve up something special no matter where you are on the Outer Banks. This shop is famous for its craveable and fresh Hawaiian shave ice – an authentic treat available in 32 flavors! That’s right – you can choose from traditional favorites such as coconut and pineapple, or go for it with tiger’s blood, cappuccino, egg custard, or blue bubble gum. If you want to level it up and make it truly great, go for a Booty Freeze – up to three flavors of shave ice with a hearty helping of mini melts in one of six melt-in-your-mouth flavors such as rainbow, cookie dough, or chocolate. Of course, ice cream is on the menu with flavors like oatmeal cookie craving, caramel cheesecake cookie monster, chocolate moose tracks, and salted caramel cookies and cream. You can put a tasty scoop between two cookies for a real treat, or have it blended into a milkshake. Just make sure you get a taste of the great local Nag’s Head restaurants first!

American Pie

Want a hot, savory treat before tempting your tastebuds with something sweet? Then American Pie is the place for you. This drive in is famous on the Outer Banks for pizza “baked to perfection and always piping hot”! You can also pile your plate high with chicken wings, burgers, Mahi or shrimp po-boys, and more. And, of course, you’ll want to finish with a scoop (or two!) of homemade ice cream in a handmade waffle cone. You can have it in store or pack a pint for the road. Flavors change daily, so head in for a little taste of adventure.

Fat Boyz

Located in the Whalebone District of South Nags Head, Fatboyz is the ideal place to get your cool on after a hot day of exploring the beach and having fun in the area. Fatboyz boasts on their website that “we regularly have a long line in the summertime,” but they say the line moves quickly. And it’s a good thing because you won’t want to wait too long for a bubbly peach cream soda or strawberry coconut soda. You can also treat yourself to a brownie ice cream sandwich, waffle cone taco, tasty banana split, or a Joe Dirt Flurry with chocolate sandwich cookies and gummy worms! Have a big party? Try a homemade ice cream cake in one of 11 tasty flavors. It’s an extensive menu with a taste that’s just right for anyone.

Dessert In Nags Head

If you want a more varied dessert experience in the Nags Head area, don’t worry – there are lots of choices! Read on to find out more about some of the best dessert options.

Kill Devil Hills Frozen Custard & Beach Fries

This eatery in Kill Devil Hills is all about the frozen custard. They have a special machine to create it and will give you a great education on the difference between frozen custard and ice cream. For now, just know they make their frozen custard fresh every hour – vanilla, chocolate, and a special flavor that changes daily. Pair your custard treat with a juicy burger and golden-brown fries – served plain, or with cheese or chili. If you’re a fan of North Carolina barbecue, check out the pulled pork served North Carolina style or an all-beef Coney Island hot dog. At this place, it’s all about simple, fresh, and delicious food.

Peace Frogs Frozen Yogurt

Can any place with a slogan, “Live fun, do good” be bad? Peace Frogs Frozen Yogurt serves up some of the finest desserts on the Outer Banks, and they sport some of the best t-shirts, branded apparel, and other fun gifts around. Get the family some inspirational t-shirts and hats, then head over to the frozen yogurt counter for a real treat. Dip into a sweet serving of strawberry lemonade, angel food cake, cookies and cream, banana island, and more. Do some good, feel good, and eat good at Peace Frogs! The best part is, it’s close to our Kill Devil Hills vacation rentals!

Surfin’ Spoon

Another place that’s mastered the clothing-and-yogurt vibe is Surfin’ Spoon. Pick up some tank tops, then slip into a warm hoodie before heading over to the ice cream sandwiches. These delicious treats are made in a peanut-free kitchen and are allergy-friendly and organic. Try the classic chocolate chip with vanilla ice cream or savor the Lemon Lavberry, featuring a lemon-flavored cookie with coconut-lavender ice cream. It’s a little taste of something different, and something you’ll truly love.

The Spot

Dessert can come in all shapes and sizes, and The Spot really does hit the spot with locations in Nags Head and Kitty Hawk. For the health-conscious, try a mermaid bowl with bananas, peaches, almonds, and more, or sip a Hatteras Sunset smoothie with peach, mango, pineapple, orange juice, and honey. Slice into a Belgian waffle covered in whip cream and syrup, take down a turtle sundae or enjoy a piece of Crumb Cake or a muffin to go. The Spot is the place where anyone can find something special.

Island Snowball Company

Want a snowball at the beach? They’re waiting at Island Snowball Company. What’s a Snowball? It’s shaved ice covered with syrup – made to order. Try the Bahama Mama or sour apple. You can get a Snowball that’s dye-free and sugar-free, in four different sizes. You’ll also find traditional, locally made ice cream, such as vanilla and chocolate, and you can top it with candy, graham crackers, and more. Smoothies and milkshakes are also available for sipping and strolling.

Sunset Slush

Sunset Slush serves the Outer Banks area, offering classic Italian ice. Create your own swirl with birthday cake, raspberry, watermelon, key lime, cotton candy, and more! This cart-based business caters to events, so be sure to check availability when you arrive on the Outer Banks.

If you want to get close to the action on the Outer Banks, Nags Head vacation rentals are the way to go! We can help you find the right property – at the right price – with the amenities you want to make your stay as sweet as the desserts you’ll find in the area. Whether it’s a one-bedroom hideaway or a six-bedroom property for the whole group, we can help you find the Outer Banks vacation rentals that will make your stay perfect.

Don’t delay. Book now!